Home › Food and Drink › Pizza place
The 10 Best Pizza Places in Boston (2026)
In a city that takes its pizza seriously, our list highlights the ten pizza places Bostonians and visitors turn to most. This ranking is built from Google reviews and updated for 2026 using a Bayesian-style weighting that balances average rating with review volume, so spots with both high scores and substantial feedback rise to the top. We looked at businesses listed under ‘Pizza’ and closely related Google categories across Boston and nearby neighborhoods, giving equal attention to well-known institutions and smaller operations with strong online reputations. Use this guide to find consistently rated options for slices, pies, and casual pizza dining around the city.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a pizza place in Boston?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Ciao! Pizza and Pasta – CHELSEA
Ciao! Pizza and Pasta – CHELSEA comes out on top by combining a near-perfect Google rating (4.8) with a very large number of reviews — 1,929 at the time of our update — and is categorized as ‘Italian.’ In our Bayesian-weighted system, that mix of high score and heavy review volume produces the strongest ranking signal. Its Chelsea location also marks it as a high-profile option outside central Boston. Those data points are why it edges ahead of other highly rated places.
The full ranking
Galleria Umberto
Galleria Umberto carries a 4.8 Google rating based on 1,349 reviews and is categorized as ‘Pizza’ at 289 Hanover St in Boston.
1349 reviews
Pizzeria Rustico
Pizzeria Rustico is rated 4.8 on Google from 410 reviews and appears in the ‘Pizza’ category at 85 Canal St.
410 reviews
Florenza
Florenza posts a 4.8 Google score from 284 reviews, is listed as ‘Pizza,’ and is located in East Boston.
284 reviews
Gary’s Pizza
Gary’s Pizza holds a 4.8 Google rating with 164 reviews and is categorized as ‘Pizza’ at 1744 Washington St.
164 reviews
Lily’s Pizza
Lily’s Pizza is listed as ‘Pizza’ on Google with a 4.8 rating drawn from 135 reviews, located at 2 Oliver St.
135 reviews
Brewer’s Fork
Brewer’s Fork registers a 4.7 Google rating from 1,667 reviews, appears in the ‘Pizza’ category, and is located in Charlestown.
1667 reviews
FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca
FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca has a 4.7 Google rating based on 836 reviews and is listed under ‘Pizza’ at 16 Derne St.
836 reviews
Lily’s Bar – Pizza – Patio
Lily’s Bar – Pizza – Patio shows a 4.7 Google rating from 542 reviews and is classified as ‘Pizza’ at 33 Batterymarch St.
542 reviews
Regina Pizzeria
Regina Pizzeria holds a 4.6 Google rating with a substantial 7,514 reviews and is categorized as ‘Pizza’ at 11 1/2 Thacher St.
7514 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How should I choose a pizza place in Boston?
Look at recent reviews for consistency in food quality and service, check the Google rating and number of reviews to gauge reliability, and consider proximity and opening hours. If you have dietary needs, verify menu options before you go.
What does a typical pizza meal cost in Boston?
Prices vary by neighborhood, portion size, and style (slice versus whole pie), so expect a range rather than a single price point. Check menus online or call ahead for current pricing to budget accurately.
What should I check before ordering for a group or event?
Confirm lead time, portion sizes, delivery or pickup policies, and any deposit or payment terms; ask about accommodations for dietary restrictions. Getting these details in writing helps avoid surprises on the day of the event.
How is this ranking built and updated?
This list is derived from Google review data and uses a Bayesian-weighted approach that combines average rating with review count, so places with both high scores and sizable review samples rank higher. Entries were pulled and updated for 2026 to reflect current ratings and review volumes.